Fits Many Models
Fits Many Models
![]() |
Model-based Tuning Methods for Pid Controllers
The manner in which a measured process variable responds over time to changes in the controller output signal is fundamental to the design and tuning of a PID controller. The best way to learn about the dynamic behavior of a process is to perform experiments, commonly referred to as "bump tests." Critical to success is that the process data generated by the bump test be descriptive of actual process behavior. Discussed are the qualities required for "good" dynamic data and methods for modeling the dynamic data for controller design. Parameters from the dynamic model are not only used in correlations to compute tuning values, but also provide insight into controller design parameters such as loop sample time and whether dead time presents a performance challenge. It is becoming increasingly common for dynamic studies to be performed with the controller in automatic (closed loop). For closed loop studies, the dynamic data is generated by bumping the set point. The method for using closed loop data is illustrated. Concepts in this work are illustrated using a level control simulation.
FORM OF THE CONTROLLER
The methods discussed here apply to the complete family of PID algorithms. Examples presented will explore the most popular controller of the PID family, the Proportional-Integral (PI) controller:
In this controller, u(t) is the controller output and is the controller bias. The tuning parameters are controller gain, , and reset time, . Because is in the denominator, smaller values of reset time provide a larger weight to (increase the influence of) the integral term.
CONTROLLER DESIGN PROCEDURE
Designing any controller from the family of PID algorithms entails the following steps:
specifying the design level of operation,
collecting dynamic process data as near as practical to this design level,
fitting a first order plus dead time (FOPDT) model to the process data, and
using the resulting model parameters in a correlation to obtain initial controller tuning values.
The form of the FOPDT dynamic model is:
[2]
where y(t) is the measured process variable and u(t) is the controller output signal. When Eq. 2 is fit to the test data, the all-important parameters that describe the dynamic behavior of the process result:
Steady State Process Gain,
Overall Process Time Constant,
Apparent Dead Time,
These three model parameters are important because they are used in correlations to compute initial tuning values for a variety of controllers [1]. The model parameters are also important because:
the sign of indicates the sense of the controller (+ reverse acting; – direct acting)
the size of indicates the maximum desirable loop sample time (be sure sample time )
the ratio indicates whether a Smith predictor would show benefit (useful if )
the dynamic model itself can be employed within the architecture of feed forward, Smith predictor, decoupling and other model-based controller strategies.
DEFINING GOOD PROCESS TEST DATA
As discussed above, the collection and analysis of dynamic process data are critical steps in controller design and tuning. A "good" set of data contains controller output to measured process variable data that is descriptive of the dynamic character of the process. To obtain such a data set, the answer to all of these questions about your data should be "yes" [1]. Ultimately, it is your responsibility to consider these steps to ensure success.
Was the process at steady state before data collection started?
Suppose a controller output change forces a dynamic response in a process, but the data file only shows the tail end of the response without showing the actual controller output change that caused the dynamics in the first place. Popular modeling tools will indeed fit a model to this data, but it will skew the fit in an attempt to account for an unseen "invisible force." This model will not be descriptive of your actual process and hence of little value for control. To avoid this problem, it is important that data collection begin only after the process has settled out. The modeling tool can then properly account for all process variations when fitting the model.
Did the test dynamics clearly dominate the process noise?
When generating dynamic process data, it is important that the change in controller output cause a
response in the process that clearly dominates the measurement noise. A rule of thumb is to define a
noise band of ±3 standard deviations of the random error around the process variable during steady
operation. Then, when during data collection, the change in controller output should force the process variable to move at least ten times this noise band (the signal to noise ratio should be greater than ten). If you meet or exceed this requirement, the resulting process data set will be rich in the dynamic information needed for controller design.
Were the disturbances quiet during the dynamic test?
It is essential that the test data contain process variable dynamics that have been clearly (and in the ideal world exclusively) forced by changes in the controller output as discussed in step 2. Dynamics caused by unmeasured disturbances can seriously degrade the accuracy of an analysis because the modeling tool will model those behaviors as if they were the result of changes in the controller output signal. In fact, a model fit can look perfect, yet a disturbance that occurred during data collection can cause the model fit to be nonsense. If you suspect that a disturbance event has corrupted test data, it is conservative to rerun the test.
Did the model fit appear to visually approximate the data plot?
It is important that the modeling tool display a plot that shows the model fit on top of the data. If the two lines don't look similar, then the model fit is suspect. Of course, as discussed in step 3, if the data has been corrupted by unmeasured disturbances, the model fit can look great yet the usefulness of the analysis can be compromised.
NOISE BAND AND SIGNAL TO NOISE RATIO
When generating dynamic process data, it is important that the change in the controller output signal causes a response in the measured process variable that clearly dominates the measurement noise. One way to quantify the amount of noise in the measured process variable is with a noise band. As illustrated in Fig. 1, a noise band is based on the standard deviation of the random error in the measurement signal when the controller output is constant and the process is at steady state. Here the noise band is defined as ±3 standard deviations of the measurement noise around the steady state of the measured process variable (99.7% of the signal trace is contained within the noise band). While other definitions of the noise band have been proposed, this definition is conservative when used for controller design.
When generating dynamic process data, the change in controller output should cause the measured process variable to move at least ten times the size of the noise band. Expressed concisely, the signal to noise ratio should be greater than ten. In Fig. 1, the noise band is 0.25°C. Hence, the controller output should be moved far and fast enough during a test to cause the measured exit temperature to move at least 2.5°C. This is a minimum specification. In practice it is conservative to exceed this value.
Figure 1 – Noise Band Encompasses ± 3 Standard Deviations Of The Measurement Noise
CONTROLLER TUNING FROM CORRELATIONS
The recommended tuning correlations for controllers from the PID family are the Internal Model Control (IMC) relations [1]. These are an extension of the popular lambda tuning correlations and include the added sophistication of directly accounting for dead time in the tuning computations.
The first step in using the IMC (lambda) tuning correlations is to compute, , the closed loop time constant. All time constants describe the speed or quickness of a response. The closed loop time constant describes the desired speed or quickness of a controller in responding to a set point change. Hence, a small (a short response time) implies an aggressive or quickly responding controller. The closed loop time constants are computed as:
Aggressive Tuning: (See online version for picture of formula)
Moderate Tuning: ("")
Conservative Tuning: ("")
Final tuning is verified on-line and may require tweaking. If the process is responding sluggishly to disturbances and changes in the set point, the controller gain is too small and/or the reset time is too large. Conversely, if the process is responding quickly and is oscillating to a degree that makes you uncomfortable, the controller gain is too large and/or the reset time is too small.
EXAMPLEs: In online copy
PI Controller Tuning Map
Figure 6 – How PI controller tuning parameters impact set point tracking performance
CONCLUSIONS
Understanding the dynamic behavior of a process is essential to the proper design and tuning of a PID controller. The recommended design and tuning methodology is to: step, pulse or otherwise perturb the controller output near the design level of operation, record the controller output and measured process variable data as the process responds, and fit a first order plus dead time (FOPDT) dynamic model to this process data, use the dynamic model parameters in a correlation to compute P-Only, PI, PID and PID with Filter test your controller to ensure satisfactory performance.
LITERATURE CITED
1. Cooper, Douglas, "Practical Process Control Using Control Station," Published by Control Station,
Inc, Storrs, CT (2004).
For more information about model-based tuning techniques and technologies, please see our other resources below:
PID Control – Practical Process Control Training (2 Day Workshop)
http://www.bin95.com/process_control_atlanta_training.htm
Complete list of authors:
Jeffrey Arbogast – Department of Chemical Engineering
Douglas J. Cooper, PhD – Control Station, Inc.
Robert C. Rice, PhD – Control Station, Inc.
To see the full online version with pictures, please visit http://www.bin95.com/PID_Controller_Design.htm
About the Author
More from these authors and much more. please see ”More PID TRaining resources”...
|
|
Simple Models of Many-Fermion Systems $129 The purpose of this book is to provide a pedestrians route to the physics of many-particle systems. The material is developed along simple and generic models which allow to illuminate the basic mechanisms beyond each approach and which apply to broad variety of systems in different areas of physics and chemistry. The book is sorted in steps of slowly increasing complexity of the models. Complementing numerical tools help to carry on where analytical methods reach their limits. They provide at the same time a useful training for the typical numerical methods in many-body physics. In order to confine the huge field, we shall focus the discussions on finite systems wherefrom we take the examples of applications. This covers nuclei, atoms, molecules and clusters. The idea of this book is to concentrate first on the generic, robust and simple, approaches and show how they apply to several domains across the specific disciplines. On the other hand, we aim to establish contact with actual research by carrying forth some examples up to realistic applications, attacked with help of a set of simple and still general codes provided on a CD-ROM complementing the book. This latter aspect emphasizes our intention to guide the reader in "practizing" the tools presented in the book, both at schematic and realistic levels. |
|
|
View Showing Many Miniature Boat Models $79.99 Hansel Mieth View Showing Many Miniature Boat Models - Premium Photographic Print |
|
|
Simple Models of Many-Fermions Systems $125.78 No Synopsis Available |
|
|
Lady Models One of the Many Styles of Undies Available from This Company $49.99 Lady Models One of the Many Styles of Undies Available from This Company - Giclee Print |
|
|
Bach Stradivarius Bottom Valve Cap Fits Lightweight Models - Lacquer $4.99 Bach Stradivarius Bottom Valve Cap Fits Lightweight Models - Lacquer |
|
|
Clear Grease Gun Tube For Lnc1134 And Competitive Models $50.95 ? Fits Lincoln 1134 grease gun only plus many competitive models ? The clear design enables positive grease type identification (bulk or cartridge) ? Visual confirmation of quantity of grease remaining in tube (bulk) ? Visual confirmation of air pockets eliminating the loss of prime (bulk) ? Visual confirmation of grease separation or contamination (bulk) ? Perfect concentricity and resilience eliminates bypass (bulk or cartridge) ? Visual recognition of grease brand promotes quality of shop (cartridge)By Lincoln Lubrication. |
|
|
Weibull Models $170 A comprehensive perspective on Weibull models The literature on Weibull models is vast, disjointed, and scattered across many different journals. Weibull Models is a comprehensive guide that integrates all the different facets of Weibull models in a single volume. This book will be of great help to practitioners in reliability and other disciplines in the context of modeling data sets using Weibull models. For researchers interested in these modeling techniques, exercises at the end of each chapter define potential topics for future research. Organized into seven distinct parts, Weibull Models: Covers model analysis, parameter estimation, model validation, and application Serves as both a handbook and a research monograph. As a handbook, it classifies the different models and presents their properties. As a research monograph, it unifies the literature and presents the results in an integrated manner Intertwines theory and application Focuses on model identification prior to model parameter estimation Discusses the usefulness of the Weibull Probability plot (WPP) in the model selection to model a given data set Highlights the use of Weibull models in reliability theory Filled with in-depth analysis, Weibull Models pulls together the most relevant information on this topic to give everyone from reliability engineers to applied statisticians involved with reliability and survival analysis a clear look at what Weibull models can offer. |
|
|
Gemeinhardt Flute Cases and Covers C3 Case - Fits C-Foot Models 2SP, 3, 3SH $49.95 Gemeinhardt offers a wide variety of cases and case covers specifically designed to protect each model's key configurations. These cases and covers are durably crafted to withstand years of wear. The CFPB cases come standard on model 3B, 3SB, and 3SHB, but many other B-Foot flutes fit with no problem. Adding a nylon or vinyl case cover is the perfect way to insure the longest life possible to your case, as well as allowing for extra storage. |
|
|
Gemeinhardt Flute Cases and Covers CFPB Case - Fits B-Foot Models 3B, 3SB, 3SHB $84.95 Gemeinhardt offers a wide variety of cases and case covers specifically designed to protect each model's key configurations. These cases and covers are durably crafted to withstand years of wear. The CFPB cases come standard on model 3B, 3SB, and 3SHB, but many other B-Foot flutes fit with no problem. Adding a nylon or vinyl case cover is the perfect way to insure the longest life possible to your case, as well as allowing for extra storage. |
|
|
Gemeinhardt Flute Cases And Covers C3 Case - Fits C-Foot Models 2Sp, 3, 3Sh $49.95 Gemeinhardt offers a wide variety of cases and case covers specifically designed to protect each model's key configurations. These cases and covers are durably crafted to withstand years of wear. The CFPB cases come standard on model 3B, 3SB, and 3SHB, but many other B-Foot flutes fit with no problem. Adding a nylon or vinyl case cover is the perfect way to insure the longest life possible to your case, as well as allowing for extra storage. |
|
|
Gemeinhardt Flute Cases And Covers Cfpb Case - Fits B-Foot Models 3B, 3Sb, 3Shb $84.95 Gemeinhardt offers a wide variety of cases and case covers specifically designed to protect each model's key configurations. These cases and covers are durably crafted to withstand years of wear. The CFPB cases come standard on model 3B, 3SB, and 3SHB, but many other B-Foot flutes fit with no problem. Adding a nylon or vinyl case cover is the perfect way to insure the longest life possible to your case, as well as allowing for extra storage. |
|
|
Marginal Models $74.95 Presents an overview of the basic principles of marginal modeling and offers a range of possible applications. This book includes many real world examples, explains the types of research questions for which marginal modeling is useful, and provides a description of how to apply marginal models for a great diversity of research questions. |
|
|
GE TL26156/TL96156 Fits many Panasonic Sony Toshiba Uniden $20.33 Fits many Panasonic Sony Toshiba Uniden. 3.6 V.400 mAh. Nickel Cadmium. Rechargeable Battery. Compatible with: Panasonic Sony Uniden and Toshiba Phones. |
|
|
Models in Bottles Models in Bottles $53.24 This unusual early work was written with a view to affording a new and interesting hobby for those pursuing the various branches of Arts and Crafts. Extensively illustrated with full page diagrams and 8 full page plates. Contents Include: Old Methods and Their Limits; A Brief Explanation of the New Sectional System; Galleons With Hulls Oversize to the Bottleneck; The Early Paddle Steamer; The Old English Windmill; Windmill (Using Two Separate Sectioned Units); Figure Bottling; The Stage Coach; Old English Buildings. Many of the earliest books, particularly those dating back to the 1900s and before, are now extremely scarce and increasingly expensive. We are republishing these classic works in affordable, high quality, modern editions, using the original text and artwork. Author: Bartley, R. Binding Type: Hardcover Number of Pages: 108 Publication Date: 2010/07/27 Language: English Dimensions: 5.50 x 8.50 x 0.38 inches |
|
|
Many Splendors $5.99 STAR TREK ™ S.C.E. #66 STARFLEET CORPS OF ENGINEERS WHAT'S PAST A special six-part S.C.E. event that flashes back to previous adventures of the S.C.E. crew from the 23rd century to the height of the Dominion War, with special guests from all across the Star Trek universe! 2365-2368: Starfleet Academy graduate Sonya Gomez has received her dream assignment: the Starship Enterprise ™. Captained by Jean-Luc Picard and working under the supervision of Chief Engineer Geordi La Forge, Gomez hopes to make her mark on the flagship. Her initial months are difficult -- an incident involving Picard and a cup of hot chocolate is followed by a brutal encounter with the Borg -- but Gomez slowly begins to find her place on the Enterprise even as the ship deals with crises, from the Pakleds to the Ferengi to a return engagement with the Borg. But it is her colleague, Kieran Duffy, who proves to be her greatest challenge, as the driven young woman must decide if a relationship is something that fits with her notion of a Starfleet career.... MANY SPLENDORS |
|
|
Redcat Racing 8702 Truck Body - Red and Yellow Fits all Avalanche models $26.88 1/8 Truck body red and yellow fits all avalanche models. |
|
|
Redcat Racing 8702 Truck Body Red and Yellow Fits all Avalanche models $33.28 1/8 Truck body red and yellow fits all avalanche models. |
|
|
Market Models $190.64 Market Models provides an authoritative and up-to-date treatment of the use of market data to develop models for financial analysis. Written by a leading figure in the field of financial data analysis, this book is the first of its kind to address the vital techniques required for model selection and development. Model developers are faced with many decisions, about the pricing, the data, the statistical methodology and the calibration and testing of the model prior to implementation. It is important to make the right choices and Carol Alexander`s clear exposition provides valuable insights at every stage. In each of the 13 Chapters,Market Models presents real world illustrations to motivate theoretical developments. The accompanying CD contains spreadsheets with data and programs; this enables you to implement and adapt many of the examples. The pricing of options using normal mixture density functions to model returns; the use of Monte Carlo simulation to calculate the VaR of an options portfolio; modifying the covariance VaR to allow for fat-tailed P&L distributions; the calculation of implied, EWMA and `historic` volatilities; GARCH volatility term structure forecasting; principal components analysis; and many more are all included. Carol Alexander brings many new insights to the pricing and hedging of options with her understanding of volatility and correlation, and the uncertainty which surrounds these key determinants of option portfolio risk. Modelling the market risk of portfolios is covered where the main focus is on a linear algebraic approach; the covariance matrix and principal component analysis are developed as key tools for the analysis of financial systems. The traditional time series econometric approach is also explained with coverage ranging from the application cointegration to long-short equity hedge funds, to high-frequency data prediction using neural networks and nearest neighbour algorithms. Throughout this text t |
|
|
Designing with Models $65 The newly updated guide to design process modeling techniques Designing with Models, Third Edition is the revised, step-by-step guide to basic and advanced design process modeling. This comprehensive text explains the process from start to finish, and has been expanded to include up-to-date information on digital modeling programs and rapid prototyping processes. The impact of this new wave of 3D modeling technology is examined through interviews and numerous examples from renowned architects. Along with many new student projects, this new Third Edition features information on cutting-edge digital imaging equipment and design software, as well as many new process models from celebrated professional projects. Architect Criss Mills acquaints architecture and design professionals with essential modeling terms, design processes, equipment, materials, and construction methods. Fully updated with nearly 200 new photos and twenty-six new projects from students and firms, Designing with Models, Third Edition walks readers through the basics of: Material and tool selection Construction techniques Determining scale Generating ideas Exploring design processes and alternatives Modifying design work directly on the model Developing design work through modeling scale Offering increased emphasis on transitioning from hand craft to digital craft, this thorough Third Edition also provides easy-to-follow guidelines for modeling with advanced tools and materials, demonstrating how to: Master the modeling of curvilinear components with planar material and casting techniques Explore ideas with mixed media, such as wood, found objects, metal rods and screens, clay, and Plexiglas Work backwards from model information to produce 2D plan, section, and elevation drawings Record and communicate 3D design work Begin exploring the safe and effective use of power tools, such as belt sanders, table saws, drills, band saws, and welding equipment |
|
|
For As Many As Will $11.49 For As Many As Will |
|
|
Models of the Church $14.95 "One of America's leading theologians defines the basic functions of the Church, assesses its mission on Earth, and explores its many different roles in the lives of believers." |
|
|
Programming Many-Core Chips $129 This book presents new concepts, techniques and promising programming models for designing software for chips with "many" (hundreds to thousands) processor cores. Given the scale of parallelism inherent to these chips, software designers face new challenges in terms of operating systems, middleware and applications. This will serve as an invaluable, single-source reference to the state-of-the-art in programming many-core chips. Coverage includes many-core architectures, operating systems, middleware, and programming models. |
|
|
Beautiful Models $101.4 This invaluable book provides a broad introduction to the fascinating and beautiful subject of many-body quantum systems that can be solved exactly. The subject began with Bethe's famous solution of the one-dimensional Heisenberg magnet more than 70 years ago, soon after the invention of quantum mechanics. |



US $24.00





























































































